Sony sued over Killzone: Shadow Fall's 1080p promises

4.6
A California class-action lawsuit alleges Sony Computer Entertainment America engaged in "deceptive marketing" of Killzone: Shadow Fall for PS4 when it advertised the game running in 1080p. After launch, Digital Foundry found that the multiplayer portion of Shadow Fall runs in upscaled 960 x 1080 resolution, a step below 1080p – and law firm Edelson PC and plaintiff Douglas Ladore see a case there.

The suit, on behalf of Ladore and "all others similarly situated," seeks damages of more than $5 million. It also calls for Sony to more accurately advertise Shadow Fall's multiplayer resolution.

"Sony admitted that it did not in fact design Killzone to display multiplayer graphics in 1080p, but instead used a technological shortcut that was supposed to provide 'subjectively similar' results," the suit argues. "But Sony never advertised and convinced consumers to buy a technological shortcut."



After the game launched and Digital Foundry's report, Sony producer Poria Torkan addressed Shadow Fall's multiplayer graphics: "In multiplayer mode, however, we use a technique called 'temporal reprojection,' which combines pixels and motion vectors from multiple lower-resolution frames to reconstruct a full 1080p image. If native means that every part of the pipeline is 1080p then this technique is not native."

The suit describes how intently Ladore researched Shadow Fall's 1080p promises before purchasing it, and takes us through his unboxing and first playthrough. "After opening Killzone's packaging (thus rendering the game un-returnable) and playing the game, Plaintiff realized that the game's multiplayer graphics were not the '1080p' graphics that Sony advertised," the case reads. "Instead, Plaintiff noticed that Killzone's multiplayer graphics were blurry and did not appear to be rendering at a native 1080p resolution."

The suit was filed with the Northern California US District Court on August 5, and it demands a trial by jury.

Posted:
Related Forum: PlayStation Forum

Source: http://www.joystiq.com/2014/08/06/sony-sued-over-killzone-shadow-falls-1080p-promises/

Comments

"Sony sued over Killzone: Shadow Fall's 1080p promises" :: Login/Create an Account :: 49 comments

If you would like to post a comment please signin to your account or register for an account.

vWatsoncPosted:

Sony was trying to oversale it, classic

PryzelPosted:

This seems like such a stupid argument but from the legal side of things they are right...

gtapro151Posted:

itomni
CM_Punk_BITW 5 millions for a 60 bucks game facepalm :/


They sued over false advertising not the quality they lied to make themselves sound better.


they did not lie its only the multiplayer portion of it not single player they just dident disclose that

gtapro151Posted:

why do they feel they deserve anything lol what about everyone else that bought the game jeez give me a break

DeluxeHazardPosted:

Ortho
Kex Cant believe no one has sued Gta v yet for Heists. But I never knew the game wasnt 1080p. Sucks for Sony.


GTA had it's own Lohan or whatever problem lol


One reason Rockstar haven't released Heists yet is due to the countless exploits, glitches, and hacks they have to patch.

KatsumiPosted:

Well... it is deceptive/misleading advertising, which is indeed illegal. As to be expected really

-CorgiPosted:

CM_Punk_BITW
Ortho
itomni
CM_Punk_BITW 5 millions for a 60 bucks game facepalm :/


They sued over false advertising not the quality they lied to make themselves sound better.


Even though it's stupid, but it's a pretty legit case


alright, let me fly over the big see and let me sue activison for false advertising. because they said that ghosts will have dedicated servers on the x1, which it doesn't have, maybe i should sue them for 1 billion or even more.


Too bad Ghosts technically does have dedicated servers. It's using a hybrid system, which is a combination of dedicated and listen. It all depends on your internet connection to be put in a dedicated server. Also, Infinity Ward stated that, not Activision. Get your facts straight, or you won't be winning any court case.

On topic: Serves them right.

Third_EyePosted:

It's a shame next-gen consoles aren't able to meet an almost last-gen standard. With their upscaling trash, they deserve this. I hope to see big money lost.

Mercedes_BenzPosted:

Ortho
itomni
CM_Punk_BITW 5 millions for a 60 bucks game facepalm :/


They sued over false advertising not the quality they lied to make themselves sound better.


Even though it's stupid, but it's a pretty legit case


alright, let me fly over the big see and let me sue activison for false advertising. because they said that ghosts will have dedicated servers on the x1, which it doesn't have, maybe i should sue them for 1 billion or even more.

TomPosted:

Cant believe no one has sued Gta v yet for Heists. But I never knew the game wasnt 1080p. Sucks for Sony.