Didn't Even Break a Sweat
Have your starting pitcher throw a complete game with 58 or fewer pitches thrown (only earned if playing an uninterrupted 9-inning game against the CPU, without switching sides or fast forwarding).

---

This is one of the greatest pitching feats in MLB history, and it would be nearly impossible to match in real life. Fortunately, we have the ability to edit the game to achieve desired results. They key to this trophy is to not strike out anyone, or walk anybody, but instead, have the CPU put the ball in play. You need to average less than 6.5 pitches per inning. Make sure you're playing against a team that you have completely edited all their attributes to the minimum.

To do this, we are going to do some outside the box tweaking. First, edit your CPU team to have maximum Plate Vision in edit a player. Then, go and edit your starting pitcher you are planning on using. Now edit his Pitching Attributes and lower the following:

H/9
K/9
Also lower his pitch speeds. Not necessarily all the way, but we are trying to induce contact with the opposing teams bat. Next, Increase the following sliders:

CPU Contact
CPU Timing
Fielder Run Speed
Fielder Reaction
Human Starter Stamina
Baserunner Steal Frequency
Baserunner Steal Ability
And lower the following:

Fielding Errors
Throwing Errors
Baserunner Speed
This should be enough for you to get the 27 outs you need in under 59 pitches, but there's one last thing you can do. For your opposing team, edit their roster and increase their speed attribute to 50% and increase BR Aggressiveness to max. This way, if you allow a hit you can wipe them out on a steal attempt.

---