Microsoft recognizes YouTubers as influential but wants rules

4.7
A recent marketing promotion between Microsoft and Machinima has sparked a discussion about the ethics of how YouTubers make a living. Ars Technica has a piece detailing a recent promotion where Microsoft (through Machinima) could pay YouTubers up to $3,750 for a video featuring Xbox One content, with the proviso that the YouTuber could not say "anything negative or disparaging about Machinima, Xbox One or any of its Games in your Campaign Video."

Reaction to the story has been mixed. Product placement is nothing new and some dismiss it as standard marketing practice, while others are raising questions about ethical concerns. Do or should YouTubers have to acknowledge when they are being paid to play or discuss a particular product?

Posted:
Related Forum: Social Media

Source: http://www.joystiq.com/2014/01/20/microsoft-recognizes-youtubers-as-influential-but-wants-rules/

Comments

"Microsoft recognizes YouTubers as influential but wants rules" :: Login/Create an Account :: 63 comments

If you would like to post a comment please signin to your account or register for an account.

StonerzardPosted:

Lately I've felt like MS care more for money than customer satisfaction, and Sony are the other way round. It's a shame because I loved a lot of Xbox exclusives

-Excite-Posted:

I can see where they are coming from if you choose to be paid you should not say anything if you choose not to it is fine.

DongPosted:

FouLR This is very unfair to people. If I watch an review on an Xbox One, I want an honest review. Not some sellout feeding me lies.


I agree, but that's what this world has come to. It's all about making something sounds better than it really is.

ZoidbergPosted:

So they're getting paid without telling you the downsides or the critical flaws you need to be aware of..? If I see a review I think a key point of the review should be the negative things about it.

DerangedPosted:

FouLR This is very unfair to people. If I watch an review on an Xbox One, I want an honest review. Not some sellout feeding me lies.


Wow youre dumb just because they say promote a product doesnt make ANY of it a lie, i can say a ton of amazing things about the console and just not tell you any of the downsides/issues/ or even where they could improve..

Just because you leave out some issues doesnt make any of the good things said about it a lie

"Ignorance is Bliss" though so go ahead an make a fuss over more shit you wont understand until they dumb it down or just throw it out for you

7O2Posted:

I hope the dummys of YouTube don't get allowed to do anything regarding games. (ex. PewDiePie)

Martin_Luther_PingPosted:

I don't see the big deal. All Microsoft did was say that if you didn't pinpoint the bad things about the system then you could get a little extra money. Not forcing you to do it either.

T0RONTOPosted:

Honest reviews are the best but it's marketing and thats what Microsoft wants

IntPosted:

Crowns
Obi-Wan 4k for for 1 vid? i think you would probably have to have a decent fanbase.


Yeah that's probably a requirement


Yep people can see whats happening but nobody is standing up for it.

IntPosted:

FouLR This is very unfair to people. If I watch an review on an Xbox One, I want an honest review. Not some sellout feeding me lies.


Yup, truly said pal the entertainment industry is corrupted in every aspect now.