You are viewing our Forum Archives. To view or take place in current topics click here.

Liquid or Air cooling

Liquid
33.33% (1 vote)
Air
66.67% (2 votes)

Total Votes: 3

Gaming PC help. Liquid VS Air cooling
Posted:

Gaming PC help. Liquid VS Air coolingPosted:

F3arxt0psh0t
  • Powerhouse
Status: Offline
Joined: Jun 23, 201112Year Member
Posts: 445
Reputation Power: 19
Status: Offline
Joined: Jun 23, 201112Year Member
Posts: 445
Reputation Power: 19
For Christmas I am building a gaming PC this is my first desktop but not my first PC.
I am getting the ASUS Rampage IV motherboard and the Intel I7 3930K LGA 2011 Processor. I want to overclock it to 4.2Ghz So i was wondering if i need to go to liquid cooling or if a normal air cooling heat sink will work, I was looking at either the Corsair hydro h100 or h80 for liquid and a Noctua for air cooling. Thanks in advance.
#2. Posted:
Generation
  • TTG Champion
Status: Offline
Joined: Nov 06, 201013Year Member
Posts: 8,002
Reputation Power: 426
Status: Offline
Joined: Nov 06, 201013Year Member
Posts: 8,002
Reputation Power: 426
I guarantee you won't need a $300 motherboard or the overpriced 3930K either.

Grab a MSI Z77 G43 + I5 3570K + Hyper 212.
#3. Posted:
Buxtyyyy
  • TTG Senior
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 24, 201211Year Member
Posts: 1,447
Reputation Power: 64
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 24, 201211Year Member
Posts: 1,447
Reputation Power: 64
I'm by no means an expert, but liquid cooling is extremely effective. A bit harder to install but probably worth it.
#4. Posted:
Generation
  • TTG Champion
Status: Offline
Joined: Nov 06, 201013Year Member
Posts: 8,002
Reputation Power: 426
Status: Offline
Joined: Nov 06, 201013Year Member
Posts: 8,002
Reputation Power: 426
tbyeah wrote I'm by no means an expert, but liquid cooling is extremely effective. A bit harder to install but probably worth it.


It's just as effective as air cooling but worse bang for your buck.

An $80 H80 is going to get absolutely crushed by a $80 Noctua NH-D14 / Phanteks CPU cooler.

Small surface area + closed looped + expensive = not worth it.
#5. Posted:
Buxtyyyy
  • TTG Senior
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 24, 201211Year Member
Posts: 1,447
Reputation Power: 64
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 24, 201211Year Member
Posts: 1,447
Reputation Power: 64
Generation wrote
tbyeah wrote I'm by no means an expert, but liquid cooling is extremely effective. A bit harder to install but probably worth it.


It's just as effective as air cooling but worse bang for your buck.

An $80 H80 is going to get absolutely crushed by a $80 Noctua NH-D14 / Phanteks CPU cooler.

Small surface area + closed looped + expensive = not worth it.


Like I said, I'm no expert. However, my cousin most definitely is. He told me that liquid was indeed more expensive, but worked better. Surely just by logic liquid is better? In the same way they use liquid cooling instead of air cooling in industry when machinery is really hot.
#6. Posted:
r00t
  • Administrator
Status: Offline
Joined: May 18, 201113Year Member
Posts: 16,361
Reputation Power: 24344
Status: Offline
Joined: May 18, 201113Year Member
Posts: 16,361
Reputation Power: 24344
tbyeah wrote
Generation wrote
tbyeah wrote I'm by no means an expert, but liquid cooling is extremely effective. A bit harder to install but probably worth it.


It's just as effective as air cooling but worse bang for your buck.

An $80 H80 is going to get absolutely crushed by a $80 Noctua NH-D14 / Phanteks CPU cooler.

Small surface area + closed looped + expensive = not worth it.

Like I said, I'm no expert. However, my cousin most definitely is. He told me that liquid was indeed more expensive, but worked better. Surely just by logic liquid is better? In the same way they use liquid cooling instead of air cooling in industry when machinery is really hot.

It's all about getting lower temp deltas for the price. Sure, you could shell out a few hundred bucks for a basic custom water loop, but it's just not going to give you a few hundred bucks of performance. Of course it will cool better, but you have to know what to buy for the loop, how to install it, how to maintain it, and how to make the most of it. The extra performance and effort doesn't justify the price at all. High-end sealed air coolers perform on par with high-end air coolers like the Noctua NH-D14 and Phanteks PH-TC14PE, but are more expensive. The H100 can perform better if it's outfitted with more, better fans, but then you're looking at a huge chunk of change for a cooler. Again, price:performance.

That's why we don't recommend water. Some setups necessitate sealed coolers and sometimes a decked out H100 is the way to go for very high-budget builds.
#7. Posted:
CMR
  • TTG Senior
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 18, 201013Year Member
Posts: 1,609
Reputation Power: 73
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 18, 201013Year Member
Posts: 1,609
Reputation Power: 73
tbyeah wrote
Generation wrote
tbyeah wrote I'm by no means an expert, but liquid cooling is extremely effective. A bit harder to install but probably worth it.


It's just as effective as air cooling but worse bang for your buck.

An $80 H80 is going to get absolutely crushed by a $80 Noctua NH-D14 / Phanteks CPU cooler.

Small surface area + closed looped + expensive = not worth it.


Like I said, I'm no expert. However, my cousin most definitely is. He told me that liquid was indeed more expensive, but worked better. Surely just by logic liquid is better? In the same way they use liquid cooling instead of air cooling in industry when machinery is really hot.


It would be effective if the tasks you carry out would take the computer to a very high heat level, which is unlikely. Air cooling is just as efficient for standard use. You proved your own point - they use it in industries and large factories, not little computers. It's just not needed. You'll be saving a lot of money. As generation said, G43+ i5 3570k, but personally I'd go with Enermax ETS T 40.

Same thing really, but it's said to be better.
Jump to:
You are viewing our Forum Archives. To view or take place in current topics click here.