Taro wrote

To be honest, from all the artwork on TTG this is the best i've seen. Nice job mate, 10/10.

Is this the first piece you have seen by any chance?

To be fair the style itself is very generic is the word previous users have said.

It has been executed quite well however, with designing try make your own style use your own imagination, using 3D text was an old era style which has slowly become overrused in best terms, don't get me wrong it's decent just not creative.

As for the previous conversations, it's feedback mate take it in and progress!

Just so you can see what we all mean;

[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

It's not precisely the same it's just very similar.

its really nice I like the effect you have with the text as if its a reaction, so I would give it a 8/10. the one advice I can think of is changing the colors and mess around with it trying to make more ideas.

I think some designers hate feeling like they are stuck in the "old" way of designing a "banner" and always link it to that style or what first comes to mind.

I am not saying that you are getting angry towards these comments, but if you are, I wouldn't.

Personally, I despise this style and don't normally like giving a comment to it but this time I did.

-FMWK

Dang, i really like that. 10/10 m8.

Looks incredible man 10/10.

haha Great Design !!

FMWK wrote I think some designers hate feeling like they are stuck in the "old" way of designing a "banner" and always link it to that style or what first comes to mind.

I am not saying that you are getting angry towards these comments, but if you are, I wouldn't.

Personally, I despise this style and don't normally like giving a comment to it but this time I did.

-FMWK

It doesn't matter how you do 3D banners on here, people will always say it's old. Even though I try to make it look new.

LYON wrote

Taro wrote

To be honest, from all the artwork on TTG this is the best i've seen. Nice job mate, 10/10.

Is this the first piece you have seen by any chance?

To be fair the style itself is very generic is the word previous users have said.

It has been executed quite well however, with designing try make your own style use your own imagination, using 3D text was an old era style which has slowly become overrused in best terms, don't get me wrong it's decent just not creative.

As for the previous conversations, it's feedback mate take it in and progress!

Just so you can see what we all mean;

[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

It's not precisely the same it's just very similar.

I know it's feedback, but telling me to do 2D instead of 3D isn't feedback. I know 2D is alot more professional, but like I said, I don't see myself as professional, therefore I do w/e I want, 2D/3D or w/e it is. That's the fun part about designing.

Seinfeld wrote

Witt wrote Tip of advice: You should steer away from c4d pluins and photoshop gfx packs to make old CoD youtube banner style stuff. Start working on professional looking stuff rather than a bunch of layers to make a grungy image. just a tip

Oh you really just said that, C4D Plugins? Come Again?
Don't post stuff on my topic if you don't know what you're talking about.
And if I like to do CoD banners, who are you to judge? I don't stick do doing one thing, if I would like to do professional looking work I would. I just like this better for myself, than doing a professional looking banner. Because I'm not a professional.
Like I said ''C4D Plugins'' Whatever helps you sleep at night.

Click to View Content

[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

Honestly you're the one that doesn't seem to know what you're talking about...
This style has been done, and done, and done, and over done.

I mean, you executed it well though.
But I still don't like it, the grungy 3D stuff is pretty generic.

You say it's some of the best 3D work on here?
I think that's pretty egotistical... I've seen way better 3D banners.
And better yet, actual 3D designs with modelling and building, and whatnot.

I mean you can go ahead and do it if you want but it's essentially a dead end.

And don't take feedback so hard. People will till you their opinions whether it's what you wanted to hear or not.
You can't ask for feedback, then get a negative comment, and fight them, tell them its not real feedback, and say their wrong.
If you dont agree just take it into consideration for future use, and move on.