PREZA wrote

Chi wrote

First things first, since you're trying to tell me those are arrows, those are some of the shittiest arrows I've seen in my life.

Second if you want to try and say something about my experience as a designer, I suggest you take a look at my work, along with the people I've worked with throughout the YEARS. You're cleary trying to defend yourself desperately by saying this.

You're brandmark friend should probably find another path, because if he thinks a bold red text, goes with an underlined black, and grey under that, all in different styles, he must not be very recognizable. Let me tell you, along with many others, it looks like garbage. They are not aligned, they are all different styles, BLEH. Did you even try?

It's cool that you're attempting this project for your college, but it seems you're not the man for the job. At all. God forbid they give you feedback on it.

I used to do logo work, made a lot of money doing so (try digging through some of my posts you'll find some). The thing is I found it incredibly boring, uncreative, and just a way to make easy money. It's boring, doesn't allow me to show my style, and be me.

So please don't bore me with that noise.

You know nothing about experice or creativity.
The majority of your designs are glance work, but get boring after a minute.
Don't bring up experience or skill level, when you have no right to bring that sort of thing up.

Have fun with your project, and trying to convince yourself you are a half decent designer.
You can't give feedback,
You can't recieve feedback,
You're a dead end.

Thanks for letting me practice my phone typing skills aswell, that was fun.

Carry on now,
-Chi

Well, for first, if you're basing the overall design on two arrows that were created by someone who rarely uses the pen tool, then I'm sorry to say but you're just dull-witted.

Secondly, in my opinion, your work is garbage. Some designs I have found to be just dull and amateurish, which would make sense considering your that was your approach to my design.

As I said, this was a draft or a template. The University gave me 60% of the stuff to work with, including the colours, which had to be red black and grey. So I wasn't really working with much. My Brandmark friend is also, just for the record, a highly skilled, professional and qualified designer, who, as I said, specializes in Brandmark design and logo design. If you had also read my original post, I said that I had showed this design to multiple designers, who said that it was excellent, considering the amount of choice I was left to work with in the assignment, so to answer your question, yes, I did try.

And true, I must not be the man for the job. I mean anyone with an RSA Student Design award, The Graphic Design Award by Yamaha (GDAY) and several A*'s in A level Design and media clearly isn't skilled enough to create a simple, 3 colour based business logo.

Logo design being 'boring' is your opinion, and you're entitled to that. But saying that it doesn't allow you to be creative and be yourself is just stupid. It is one of the most creative types of Graphic Design out there, many others would also agree.

Let me teach you a little lesson aswell, don't dare post anything on anyone's design, stating that they know nothing about experience or creativity. That has got to be one of the most mindless and moronic things I have ever heard. God forbid anyone that has the 'pleasure' of coming across you in their career.

One more thing, anyone, and I mean anyone (and this goes for outside the bracket of Graphic Design) can give feedback and take feedback. You are obviously a very narrow minded idiot. Saying that I am a dead end is also untruthful, but I wont enlighten you with the mass range of logo's and designs I have created and have been used by big brands and names, because you obviously aren't at that level.

So to conclude that hideous attempt of a reply, thanks for enlightening me with your opinion , I be sure to try and gain the ability to 'give and take feedback' lol,

Have a very boring day:)

Fyredesigns wrote You should not try to identify yourself as an experienced or professional designer, there's always more you can work on and improve in, do not EVER take criticism for granted, especially from people who are far more experienced in the field than you are. If anything you should appreciate their efforts in giving honest opinions and do not feel offended by it. If you don't take criticism to consideration, that's on you.

PREZA wrote OMG he got me so good. I really care what some freak on TTG says about my work lol.

I cba typing a full paragraph explaining why you're wrong, but by judging by your work I can tell you already are.

Have a good day:)

"I really care what some freak on TTG says about my work lol."