FIFA 17 Players Demand Explanation After Secret Banding/Momentum Discovered

4.8
The FIFA 17 community is demanding an explanation from EA after users found evidence of ‘momentum’ – also known as scripting or rubber band difficulty – in the game’s data files.

For those who are unaware, a rubber banding system dynamically adjusts the difficulty of a game according to how well – or how badly – a player is performing. For years, publisher EA has denied claims that its flagship football series stealthily includes such a feature.

However, evidence has surfaced over the past couple of days that points to the contrary. Reddit user girlfriend_pregnant kicked off the debate after data mining FIFA 17’s game files on PC and discovering, amongst other hidden attributes including ‘super sub’, a line of code that pointed to the team chemistry stat – used in FIFA Ultimate Team (FUT) – being linked to ‘momentum’:

//— team chemistry (0-100) (used in momentum)

This initial thread launched a community-led investigation, with Reddit user Murhawk013 discovering that a recent EA Sports Spain video seemed to confirm that individual player ratings in FIFA 17 are artificially boosted depending on how they are performing in a match.

Yesterday, the poster of the original thread returned to Reddit with even more concrete evidence of the system. Another section of code, discovered by CatalystFCP, detailed various circumstances where the in-game difficulty is increased or decreased at various points throughout a match depending on various criteria, such as the total number of shots or overall possession, being met.

In the data files, the developers refer to this as “adaptive difficulty”, although it’s currently unclear whether it simply applies to player games against the AI, or online multiplayer and FUT as well.

As a result of the discovery, and confusion as to the context of its implementation, a number of users have banded together to create a campaign named #ExplainFIFAMomentum, in the hopes of prompting EA to clarify the exact nature of a feature it’s previously denied exists.

FIFA 17 players have complained that rubber banding unfairly and unrealistically influences the outcome of a game and penalises good performances, with the system open to being gamed and exploited by those who are losing a match.

If the feature does apply to FUT, it also opens a whole new can of worms with regards to players paying real money for extra in-game content, in the form of player packs, without being assured of a level playing field.

Posted:
Related Forum: EAFC Forum

Source: http://powerupgaming.co.uk/2016/12/28/fifa-17-players-demand-explanation-after-evidence-of-secret-rubber-bandingmomentum-discovered/

Comments

"FIFA 17 Players Demand Explanation After Secret Banding/Momentum Discovered" :: Login/Create an Account :: 32 comments

If you would like to post a comment please signin to your account or register for an account.

HTAFCPosted:

I really don't understand how people can moan about this? Anybody that watches football constantly should know that momentum is a massive thing in football. People just enjoy blaming EA for absolutely everything despite this being a smart thing in the game and makes it more realistic

RickPosted:

Not really at all surprising, everyone knew about this for years I still don't know why they deny it

PostMalonePosted:

people knew this was a thing, just never had the proof for it. Now it shows up and now EA have to explain themselves. Players and the keeper should not turn stupid after you score, in the 45th and the 90th. Im really curious as to what EA has to say about this

SkatesPosted:

The point here is to not lie from the start of things because now you got one real pissed off fan base. Good job EA.

DiscPosted:

i kinda starting to wanna pllay fifa more i dont even like soccer lmao

SakuPosted:

I didn't know they had this feature lol

Dover5Posted:

Anyone that has played Fifa knows there is some sort of scripting. You can just feel it when you play.

I'm glad now that their may be actual proof to back this up.

NickPosted:

This is cool actually! Grats on fifa

-YoungSinatraPosted:

Scripting has always existed in FIFA, and it's so sad not many people are aware of this. FIFA will never allow you to win or lose consecutively for a long time, hence the scripting.

ZydrinPosted:

I always thought people knew about this feature...