AdviceAmd Ryzen vs Intel i5 ?Posted:

  • 1K Rainmaker
Status: Offline
Joined: Aug 01, 20134 Year Member
Posts: 3,431
Reputation Power: 172
I currently have this build:

[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

But im looking to upgrade to something a bit better, I was in two minds as too get The Amd ryzen or an intel i5?

I know my computer is needing an upgrade but im not sure what to go with, Any ideas ?
#2. Posted:
  • 2k News Comments
Status: Offline
Joined: Aug 22, 20125 Year Member
Posts: 7,043
Reputation Power: 433
Motto: Pantsu is my Baka <3 Good and bad, I made the promise to stay at your side every step of the way. Also spells my name Yoori now.
The CPU upgrade depends on what you need to do for your system. If it's a workstation, editing or running virtual machines, I would lean more towards Ryzen for a higher core count. Ryzen works well on gaming, don't get me wrong, but I feel Ryzen shines when it's actually using all the cores it has, which, will be from the above examples -- someone feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, but a good portion of games only really utilise four cores or so.

If you were to upgrade to an i5, you could get something like an i5-4690/(k) -- which is still very relevant in 2018 if you're on a slight budget and can can't afford to upgrade to Coffee Lake/Ryzen with a brand new CPU, motherboard and RAM. If you have a budget that you are comfortable to spend on, you could upgrade your whole CPU, motherboard and of course RAM with either a Ryzen build or a Coffee Lake build.

At the end, if you go Ryzen or Coffee Lake, you will need a new motherboard, CPU and RAM. If you want to jump into an i5, the 4690 / 4690k would be a reasonable jump; however, prices on them seem to be a little higher than I remember when I got mine back in 2015, I spent around $260-ish on it and it seems now they're in the $300 area.

If you decide to do a full overhaul on your CPU, motherboard and RAM, knowing your PSU and exact case will help tremendously. I know your current motherboard is a Micro-ATX, but it needs to be known if you have a bigger case with Micro-ATX standoffs or a smaller case meant to fit the motherboard. That's just to make sure that any motherboard suggestions will fit your case.
#3. Posted:
  • Gold Member
Status: Offline
Joined: Nov 09, 20098 Year Member
Posts: 128
Reputation Power: 439
Motto: God forgives, I don't.
Give us your budget, that will be a main factor for deciding what's best suited for you.
#4. Posted:
  • Christmas!
Status: Offline
Joined: Aug 01, 20134 Year Member
Posts: 3,431
Reputation Power: 172
SHOTTYLEAN wroteGive us your budget, that will be a main factor for deciding what's best suited for you.

I dont really have a set budget, Just looking for the cheapest option. I was looking at i5's n seen around 150GBP.
#5. Posted:
  • Rated Awesome
Status: Online
Joined: Oct 05, 20134 Year Member
Posts: 14,363
Reputation Power: 1165
Motto: Thanks to Adam for gold < 3
I mean, we really can't help without more information.

You're running a pretty low resolution monitor and an aging GPU, appears to be either an R9 270 or 270x, maybe an R9 285? So, a monitor or GPU upgrade would be better than a CPU upgrade for some games. You also don't have an SSD. If you were just looking for a quick upgrade to make your system feel a little snappier, SSD is the way to go. Honestly, adding an SSD would be the first thing I'd do with this system, regardless of what I used it for.

For a CPU upgrade, you're looking at either Coffee Lake or Ryzen if you're buying new, which means at least $70 for a motherboard(up to $100), $100+ for RAM, and $200 for R5/i5. Instead of doing that, I'd grab a Haswell(Refresh) i5/i7 or Xeon, then use the remaining $200 for a nice 240GB SSD and a 1080p or 2560x1080 ultrawide monitor. Something like this;
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]
and here's a 4670k for $120;
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]
i5-4440, 4460, 4570, 4590, 4670(k), 4690(k) and Xeon E3-1220 V3 are all solid 4C/4T options that should cost between $100-125 used.
Alternatively, i7-4770(k), 4790(k) or Xeon E3-1230/1231 V3 for 4C/8T. Should be $160-170 for the locked i7 and Xeon's, but you'll probably be looking at closer to $200 for a 4790k since they're still pretty sought after.

We could help much easier/better if we knew your budget and currency, as well as what you use your system for exactly and where you feel it is lacking.
Users browsing this topic: None
Jump to: