Item description:

This walkthrough is listed in the order you should get the trophies to avoid random trophies popping out of order. If you want to use a save out of order to get easy/miscellaneous trophies faster, do so at your own risk.



Important Notes

1. To avoid issues, please do these trophies offline.
2. While testing I noticed that some trophies take a little longer to pop (#42, #43, and the plat) while offline. Be patient--everything works.



Guide

1. A Chase through the Night - Drive to the marker. Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
2. The Back Streets of Little Italy - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
3. Family History & 4. Pulp Fiction - Walk past the pool table into the bar and the cigarette card is on the third table from the right (of the tables along the windows). Then, go with Paulie to Vincenzo and the Pulp magazine is on the table adjacent to where you pick up the molotovs.
5. The Way this City Works - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
6. Gangs of Lost Haven - Finish the mission. The trophy pops once the screen goes black.
7. Supercharged - Win the race. Trophy pops during cutscene once the race is over.
8. Not Classy & 9. Neighborhood Hero - Drive to the brothel (guide). Not Classy pops as soon as you're there. Neighborhood Hero pops once the chapter ends a few seconds later.
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

10. Good Night for a Walk Anyways - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
11. Storm Cloud over Chinatown - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
12. Comic Violence - Resign both parts of the save. Go out of the room, turn left, then right, then left into Room 210 and the comic is in the bathroom. Video if you need it, but it starts from the hotel lobby whereas my save puts you 90% of the way there.
13. Murder in the House of God - Escape the cops and drive to the marker on the map. Trophy pops once the screen turns to black.
14. Mystery Fox Discovered - Go to 0:20 of this video for the location. Hold Square to pick it up.
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

15. Your Canuck Cousins - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
16. Rat in the House - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
17. Blood on Beech Hill - Finish the mission. Run left out of the gates, then straight ahead for a little bit. Once the cops are called off, get in a car and Skip Drive. The trophy pops once the screen goes black.
18. Best Laid Plans - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
19. The Day the War Began - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
20. Death on the Water - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
21. Stunt Rider - Save starts you on the motorcycle. Come to a stop, hold Circle, then R2 for a few seconds until you're revved up, then let go of Circle and pull down on the left stick. Guide.
22. When God Stops Smiling - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
23. The Day the War Ended - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscenes.
24. Quite the Collection - Resign both parts of the save. Get into the orange car in front of you.
25. Heat from the Cops - You'll have to shoot a cop or two to get the last star, then lose them. Use this video as a guide. You can just finish the mission (drive home/Skip Drive) to get A View from the Top if you want to save time resigning another save.
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

26. A View from the Top - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
27. Into the Lion’s Den - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
28. That Last Big Score - Trophy pops after the skippable cutscene.
29. Made Man, 30. Friends and Family & 31. A Life of Crime - Resign both parts of the save. Finish the mission. Trophies pop after the first skippable cutscene. Credit to SaveBoy364 for the save and xTheSolutionNOT for resigning.
32. Lined Pockets & 33. Not Taken In - Load any previous save and select Free Ride. Lined Pockets requires getting 1 star and paying the fine (just don't move when cops approach you), while Not Taken In requires 2 stars and resisting arrest by pressing Triangle when the prompt appears.
34. Car Enthusiast - Resign both parts of the save. Select Free Ride and pick the lock of 1 more car.
35. That Motor can Move - Load any previous save starting with the second one (or if using the first, then finish the chapter) and select Free Ride. If you're doing these trophies in the order I wrote them, just use the save from #34. Get the Bolt Ace from the garage, and drive across Giuliani Bridge. Set the waypoint to the beginning of the bridge and you will most likely get the trophy under the West Bridge Tunnel. Press X a few times to get that last little boost. Video if you need it here.
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

36. On the Trail - Go to Free Ride and pick up any car from this video. I recommend #3 (3:44) since it's closest to the spawn.
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

37. Car Thief Number One - Go to Free Ride and pick up car #3 from this video (3:44).
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

These trophies all use the same save, so you can get one after the other if you need all of them, or just pick and choose. Select Free Ride and follow the instructions.

38. Motor Museum - The trophy should pop as soon as you open your garage at spawn. If not, pick up car #5 from this video (5:24). Credit to SaveBoy364 for the save and xTheSolutionNOT for resigning.
39. Picture Book Connoisseur - Pick up Gangsters
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

Monthly #4 here (15:00). Credit to SaveBoy364 for the save.
40. Mystery Fox Domination - Pick up Mystery Fox #38 here (40:00). Credit to SaveBoy364 for the save.
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

41. Full Set - Pick up Cigarette Card #22 here (40:30). Credit to SaveBoy364 for the save.
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

42. Lending Library & 43. The Whole Story - Pick up Pulp Magazine #12 here (53:02). Credit to SaveBoy364 for the save.
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]