You are viewing our Forum Archives. To view or take place in current topics click here.

I'm probably an idiot...Posted:

Status: Offline
Joined: Apr 25, 20143 Year Member
Posts: 154
Reputation Power: 6
Hey guys, I'm probably just being stupid or something but is this incorrect or not?

"Why wouldn't you?"

It's annoying me because I'm pretty sure that says

"Why would not you"

which doesn't make sense...
Any help much appreciated

#2. Posted:
kidding
  • 1K Rainmaker
Status: Offline
Joined: Sep 27, 20143 Year Member
Posts: 1,199
Reputation Power: 62
It's because you're not reading the words in the correct order. It wouldn't be " Why would not you" it would be "Why would you not".
Not stupid though, good question.
#3. Posted:
BJP
  • Christmas!
Status: Online
Joined: Jun 03, 20125 Year Member
Posts: 4,149
Reputation Power: 207
Motto: "if I had the choice between killing 1000 Octopuses with a knife or letting 1 human die I would not even think twice before sending tentacles flying all over the place." - Cohle
The English language is one of the worst languages to learn if you are not a native speaker; for example:

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/cc/68/f3/cc68f38029a0caf485325d3d0a930af2.jpg

BJP
#4. Posted:
Status: Offline
Joined: Apr 25, 20143 Year Member
Posts: 154
Reputation Power: 6
kidding wroteIt's because you're not reading the words in the correct order. It wouldn't be " Why would not you" it would be "Why would you not".
Not stupid though, good question.


So is it still correct to say "Why wouldn't you?"
#5. Posted:
kidding
  • 2 Million
Status: Offline
Joined: Sep 27, 20143 Year Member
Posts: 1,199
Reputation Power: 62
heliix wrote
kidding wroteIt's because you're not reading the words in the correct order. It wouldn't be " Why would not you" it would be "Why would you not".
Not stupid though, good question.


So is it still correct to say "Why wouldn't you?"


yes if it's used in the right context.

Say for ex: HIM: "Should i take this job"
HER: "Why wouldn't you?"
#6. Posted:
iOSx
  • E3 2017
Status: Offline
Joined: Jun 17, 20116 Year Member
Posts: 2,413
Reputation Power: 125
You have it right, wouldn't is the correct way. I know this because my iPhone autocorrected it to that lol.
#7. Posted:
Status: Offline
Joined: Apr 25, 20143 Year Member
Posts: 154
Reputation Power: 6
kidding wrote
heliix wrote
kidding wroteIt's because you're not reading the words in the correct order. It wouldn't be " Why would not you" it would be "Why would you not".
Not stupid though, good question.


So is it still correct to say "Why wouldn't you?"


yes if it's used in the right context.

Say for ex: HIM: "Should i take this job"
HER: "Why wouldn't you?"


Thanks
#8. Posted:
Status: Offline
Joined: Apr 25, 20143 Year Member
Posts: 154
Reputation Power: 6
Lucritius wroteYou have it right, wouldn't is the correct way. I know this because my iPhone autocorrected it to that lol.


ahhaha, okay thanks
#9. Posted:
kidding
  • 2 Million
Status: Offline
Joined: Sep 27, 20143 Year Member
Posts: 1,199
Reputation Power: 62
heliix wrote
kidding wrote
heliix wrote
kidding wroteIt's because you're not reading the words in the correct order. It wouldn't be " Why would not you" it would be "Why would you not".
Not stupid though, good question.


So is it still correct to say "Why wouldn't you?"


yes if it's used in the right context.

Say for ex: HIM: "Should i take this job"
HER: "Why wouldn't you?"


Thanks


No problem man.
#10. Posted:
Loke
  • Tutorial Master
Status: Online
Joined: Oct 12, 20116 Year Member
Posts: 3,563
Reputation Power: 1872
Motto: You are now everything you want to pursue You are every personality trait you admired, and most importantly, you are in charge
English is confusing tbh
Jump to:
You are viewing our Forum Archives. To view or take place in current topics click here.