Xbox One reputation system not carried over from 360

4.8
The Xbox One reputation system will not incorporate information from Xbox 360 users, meaning previous troublemakers will have a chance to make a fresh start.

As part of an IGN Q&A session, chief Xbox One platform architect Marc Whitten was asked whether everyone's reputation will carry over the two systems.

"We will not carry over any of the 360 reputation scores into the new Xbox One reputation system," Whitten replied. "The majority of members will start fresh at the 'good' player level."

Whitten also made it clear, however, that the more recent troublemakers will not receive this privilege. They will instead begin with a "needs work" reputation level.

"We will be working with the Xbox Live enforcement team that has identified a small subset of members that have recently had enforcement actions taken against them", Whitten explained.

"This will give those members a chance to prove they can participate on Live fairly, and are not automatically placed in the 'Avoid Me' classification where things like SmartMatch filtering will affect them."

Microsoft first discussed the Xbox One's 'advanced troll detection' in July, with Microsoft's senior product manager Mike Lavin explaining how it worked.

"There'll be very good things that happen to people that just play their games and are good participants," Lavin told OXM. "And you'll start to see some effects if you continue to play bad or, or harass other people en masse. You'll probably end up starting to play more with other people that are more similar to you."

Posted:
Related Forum: Xbox Forum

Source: http://www.computerandvideogames.com/427515/xbox-one-reputation-system-not-carried-over-from-360/

Comments

"Xbox One reputation system not carried over from 360" :: Login/Create an Account :: 66 comments

If you would like to post a comment please signin to your account or register for an account.

Dee-BoPosted:

I dont like how it says, "And you'll start to see some effects if you continue to play bad". So if my Kd is below avg. i will be looked down on by the rep system?

slaughtercellPosted:

This rep shit will not work... I played a 15min match of Splinter Cell and I got bad rep for no reason... This is stupid cause people on Halo press avoid player so they won't be matched up with that person... Should I stop playing Halo and play a game where we all hold hands and be happy

HumanPosted:

I don't like the rep system, if you let a friend go on your account and he messes up you get put with crappy trolls. And if you want to have fun on the game you -bought- you get put with people who also troll xD
I'm pretty good at battlefield and a lot of the time I get bad rep just for killing a nemesis

Dr-PonyfilePosted:

I suppose this is a good idea giving people a fresh start but regardless of the fact that the rep system is basically useless, its a good idea.

MPAAPosted:

AwesomeSauce69
MPAA And once this new system kicks in, no one will care much like they don't for the 360, rep is meaningless. Just give people the chance to avoid player and a report to MS option for ToS breakers, that should be enough for any sane person.


I feel like reporting the players never works. I once received death threats, telling me and my family should get cancer & that he was going to find where I live and kill me. All of these messages (5) I kept in my Xbox live inbox and I reported this both on Xbox Live and the Xbox forums. This was around a month or two ago now & the guy still hasn't been banned from xbox live or had anything done to him.

It's unbelievable that someone can say this. Xbox Live reporting is failed


That's probably because they have nulled their profile IDs, I'd report them again after a while and if they still do not act, report the matter to law enforcement, that will make Xbox do something as that's against the law and MS won't want to be seen as aiding and abetting a crime.

GossipPosted:

Hope Im not apart of the needs work group.

DiniPosted:

M249 The rep system was a bit of a joke anyway... Didn't really do anything apart from let kids avoid you because you beat them.


I know right, you make people rage quit so they submit a bad player review

RaciPosted:

Well most the people that avoid others are normally mad or something... I don't like the new idea for "rep"

Dr-JPosted:

Pufferfish My current rep is terrible
12 percent preferred you
88 percent avoided you



Lol so you should be happy it's being removed, mines decent with 42% prefer and 59% avoid

AstraeusPosted:

My current rep is terrible
12 percent preferred you
88 percent avoided you