I you have a penis you're a male, if you dont have penis you're a female. Its honestly not that hard to understand.

C4s wrote I you have a penis you're a male, if you dont have penis you're a female. Its honestly not that hard to understand.

but what if you got balls but no dick, what does that make you?

Yamborghini wrote

C4s wrote I you have a penis you're a male, if you dont have penis you're a female. Its honestly not that hard to understand.

but what if you got balls but no dick, what does that make you?

A male. Women do not have testicles.

Yamborghini wrote

C4s wrote I you have a penis you're a male, if you dont have penis you're a female. Its honestly not that hard to understand.

but what if you got balls but no dick, what does that make you?

A very lucky person

If you have balls and a penis you're a male, if you have a vagina and menstrual cycles, you're a female. Plain and simple. I think it's B.S. that a guy wants me to call him MS. because he "feels" like a female. How in the hell do you know what it feels like? You're not a female so you don't know.

Think of it from a 5 year old boys eyes. Daddy says he is a girl but he has a penis and I have penis. Mommy is a girl and she doesn't. What? Is mommy a boy and me and daddy are girls? You are confusing the hell out of kids because you want to be a special snowflake who can't just leave nature alone, you need to play god.

At the end of the day, call yourself what you want but I will call you what I see. If I see a man going into a women bathroom, I'll be right there to point them in the room where homo-sapiens with a penis and testicles go. What is to stop me from identifying as a female for 5 mins to watch them do their business or set up a camera in there? It's sick and wrong.

I don't think a person is a specific gender just due to their body parts. I mean, it was a way I used to believe, but that has changed. If I woke up tomorrow with female body parts, I wouldn't just all of a sudden feel female. My brain is saying I am a male. These people were born with their brain saying their are the opposite of what they were born with. There are children out there who go through this. It is a complicated issue and shouldn't be dismissed due to preconceived notions. Listening to and learning about these people is the way to go I feel.

Yin wrote I don't think a person is a specific gender just due to their body parts. I mean, it was a way I used to believe, but that has changed. If I woke up tomorrow with female body parts, I wouldn't just all of a sudden feel female. My brain is saying I am a male. These people were born with their brain saying their are the opposite of what they were born with. There are children out there who go through this. It is a complicated issue and shouldn't be dismissed due to preconceived notions. Listening to and learning about these people is the way to go I feel.

But how does a male "know" he's a female even though he's never been a female?

002 wrote

Yin wrote I don't think a person is a specific gender just due to their body parts. I mean, it was a way I used to believe, but that has changed. If I woke up tomorrow with female body parts, I wouldn't just all of a sudden feel female. My brain is saying I am a male. These people were born with their brain saying their are the opposite of what they were born with. There are children out there who go through this. It is a complicated issue and shouldn't be dismissed due to preconceived notions. Listening to and learning about these people is the way to go I feel.

But how does a male "know" he's a female even though he's never been a female?

How do you know that you are a male? Sure, you've been told that you're a male. You've grown up with people treating you like a male, but what does being a male feel like?
Do all males experience being male in the same way? If not, how do you know? If so, how do you know?

It's a complete non sequitur in this discussion and you're acting like it's a knock down argument.

But it's quite a simple answer, a person who feels like they are a male will gravitate towards social norms associated with what is considered masculine, and a person who feels like they are a female will gravitate more towards things which social norms consider feminine.
So if you have two males and one of them wants to wear a dress and feels like that is what they are supposed to wear, they probably identify more as a female.
But of course it's a spectrum, just like sexual attraction.

They might want to pretend they're a women, but I still identify them as a boy.

Tight wrote
I don't think anyone can really say it's a fantasy or call it a disorder if they've never experienced it for themselves. Everyone experiences things in their own and unique way so as we may look at it as "weird" or "disgusting" maybe the person who's transitioning or has already transitioned sees it as this isn't who they want to be.

With that logic doctors can not diagnose people and place them in a mental hospital because the doctor himself has not experienced them.

Keeping in mind the hours of Youtube videos that I have watched from Sargon of Akkad, Undoomed, Bearing, TL;DR, and Nicholas Goroff. I can firmly say that I believe that most of the transgender movement is just people wanting attention. Most people doing this are millennials who haven't really done much with their lives. There are a very very VERY small amount of people who do experience the sensation of being in the wrong body. These people are the ones who go the extra steps to actually look like the gender they believe they are.

The MAJORITY that do this are the ones that do it for attention. They do it to be in the "mainstream" and the ride the attention train. If you claim to be a women on the inside, but on the outside have done nothing to look like a man, then you are full of shit.

I'm a 3rd year college student, and I can not stand this transgender/feminism culture that has been going around. If you are a highschool student, you do not have the mental capability to decide that you want to change genders. Transgender restrooms have no place there.

The transgender bathroom issue is another issue caused by this that does not need to exist. If you look like a man, use the men's restroom. If you look like a women, use the women's restroom. America is not a 6 year old in preschool. We do not need the government deciding what is OK in terms of restrooms. I am against transgender bath rooms, public restrooms are not a right, they are a privilege/convenience. There is nothing that is going against their rights as a human. Just because you are a special snow flake doesn't mean you are being denied rights.

TL;DR:
These 3rd wave feminist/trans rights/blacklivesmatter activist are just trying to ride the dying wave of the 60's and be anti-establishment. They just want to 'change' things. There are no rights that men have that women don't have. Cops are not targeting blacks. You can't just claim to change your gender and not play the part.